Comparison of the performance of statistical model and dynamic model to simulate extreme rainfall simulation

Document Type : Research Article


1 PhD Candidate in Climatology, Faculty of Geography, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran

2 Faculty of Geography, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran

3 Atmospheric Science and Meteorological Research Center, Tehran, Iran


Water resources have experienced serious tensions in recent years due to climate change. The current study aims to investigate dynamical and statistical downscaling in order to downscale extreme precipitation in catchment of Gorganrood River over May13-14, 1992 which led to record the extreme discharge in this region. For this purpose, two models namely SDSM and Regcm4 were used. The results showed that SDSM has very low ability to simulate extreme precipitation so that the mean absolute error (MAE) was about 20 mm in the years 1983-2012 with very low coefficients of determination of 0.18 to 0.002, whereas Regcm4 model has recorded a very high coefficient of determination and mean absolute error of the model was about 67 mm. This model, however, could not well simulate Lazoreh station precipitation, because the model takes into account the overall dynamic patterns for simulation. Weather maps analysis indicates that low pressure patterns are dominant in the western half and parts of South and Central Iran in these two days. Direction of low pressure patterns is South and West from Adan sea and the Persian Gulf as well as the Black Sea and the Mediterranean Sea. Geopotential Maps show that low-height patterns are in  500 and 850 Geopotential height in this region.


Main Subjects



    1. Qi S, Sun G, Wang Y, McNulty S.G, Moore Myers J.A. Streamflow response to climate and landuse changes in a coastal watershed in North Carolina. Trans ASABE. 2009;52:739–49.
    2. Fischer E.M, Knutti R. Detection of spatially aggregated changes in temperature and precipitation extremes. Geophys. Res.2014; Lett. 41.
    3. Paparrizos S, Maris F, Matzarakis A. Integrated analysis of present and future responses of precipitation over selected Greek areas with different climate conditions.Atmos. Res.2016; 169 (Part A): 199–208..
    4. Ahmadvand Kahrizi M,Rouhani H. Assessing the conservation impacts of climate change based on temperature projected on 21 century (Case study: Arazkoseh and Nodeh stations)).Eco Hydrology ,2017; 3( 4) :597-609.[Persian].
    5. Chen H, Xu C.Y, Guo S.Comparison and evaluation of multiple GCMs, statistical downscaling and hydrological models in the study of climate change impacts on runoff. Journal of Hydrology.2012; 434–435 : 36–45.
    6. Fowler H.J, Blenkinsop S, Tebaldi C. Linking climate change modelling to impacts studies: recent advances in downscaling techniques for hydrological modelling. Int. J. Climatol.2007; 27 (12): 1547–1578. DOI: 10.1002/joc.1556.
    7. Sunyer M.A, Madsen H, Ang P.H.A comparison of different regional climate models and statistical downscaling methods for extreme rainfall estimation under climate change. Atmospheric Research.2012; 103 : 119–128.
    8. Willems P, Vrac M. Statistical precipitation downscaling for small-scale hydrological impact investigations of climate change. Journal of Hydrology.2011; 402:193–205.
    9. Lee T, Jeong C. Nonparametric statistical temporal downscaling of daily precipitation to hourly precipitation and implications for climate change scenarios. Journal of Hydrology.2014; 510 :182–196..
    10. Mandal S, Srivastav R.K, Simonovic S.P. Use of beta regression for statistical downscaling of precipitation in the Campbell River basin, British Columbia, Canada. Journal of Hydrology.2016; 538:49–62.
    11. Asong Z.E, Khaliq M.N, Wheater H.S. Projected changes in precipitation and temperature over the Canadian Prairie Provinces using the Generalized Linear Model statistical downscaling approach. Journal of Hydrology.2016; 539:429–446.
    12. Piras M, Mascaro,G, Deidda R, Vivoni E.R. Impacts of climate change on precipitation and discharge extremes through the use of statistical downscaling approaches in a Mediterranean basin. Science of the Total Environment.2016; 543, :952–964. /j.scitotenv. 2015. 06.088.
    13. Hundecha Y, Sunyer M.A, Lawrence D, Madsen H, Willems P,Bürger G, et al. Inter-comparison of statistical downscaling methods for projection of extreme flow indices across Europe. Journal of Hydrology xxx , xxx–xxx.2016.
    14. Bhatla R, Ghosh S, Mandal B, Mall R.K, Sharma K. Simulation of Indian summer monsoon onset with different parameterization convection schemes of RegCM-4.3. Atmospheric Research.2016; 176–177:10–18. DOI:
    15. Laflamme E.M, Linder E, PanY. Statistical downscaling of regional climate model output to achieve projections of precipitation extremes. Weather and Climate Extremes.2016; 12: 15–23.
    16. Onyutha O, Tabari H, Rutkowska A, Nyeko-Ogiramoi,P, Willems P. Comparison of different statistical downscaling methods for climate change rainfall projections over the Lake Victoria basin considering CMIP3 and CMIP5.Journal of Hydro-environment Research.2016; 12: 31–45.
    17. Mohammadi, F, Zarrin,A and Babaian,I.The performance of climate models to simulate rainfall Recm4 cold period in Fars Province: A Case Study period from 1990 to 2010. Earth and Space Physics.1394; 41( 3Fall): 511-524. [Persian]
    18. Ghahraman N, Babaian I,Azadi M. Post statistical processing output Regcm4 pattern of rainfall on the North West of Iran. the study of physical geography.1394 ; 47( 3):385-398. [Persian]
    19. Jamab,Gorgan Basin.1387. [Persian].
    20. Azari M, Moradi H, Saghafian B, Faramarzi M. Effects of climate change on watershed hydrology Gorgan.soil and water J (AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND TECHNOLOGY).1392; 27( 3 July – September): 547-537.[Persian].
    21. Zarghami M., Abdi, A., Babaeian, I., Hassanzadeh, Y. and Kanani, R. Impacts of climate change on runoffs in East Azerbaijan, Iran. Global and Planetary Change.2011;, 78(3–4): 137-146.
    23. Delghandi M , Moazenzadeh R. Investigating spatiotemporal variations of precipitation and temperature over Iran under climate change condition considering AOGCM models and emission scenarios uncertainty. Eco Hydrology,2017;  3( 3): 321-331. [Persian].
    24. Giorgi F. Two-dimensional simulations of possible mesoscale effects of nuclear war fires. J. Geophys. Res. 1989;94:1127–1144. DOI: 10.1029/JD094iD01p01145.
    25. Grell G.A. prognostic evaluation of assumptions used by cumulus parameterization. Mon. Wea. Rev1993;.121: 764-787. DOI:;2.
    26. Giorgi, F., and G. T. Bates, The climatological skill of a regional model over complex terrain, Mon. Wea. Rev.1989; 117:2325–2347. DOI:;2.
    27. Sundqvist H, E Berge, and J. E Kristjansson. The effects of domain choice on summer precipitation simulation and sensitivity in a regional climate model, J. Climate.1989; 11: 2698–2712. DOI:;2.
    28. Kiehl J. T, J. J Hack, G. B Bonan, B. A Boville, B. P Breigleb, D Williamson, and P Rasch. Description of the ncar community climate model (ccm3). Tech. Rep. NCAR/TN-420+STR. National Center for Atmospheric Research, 1996.
    29. Grell G.A. prognostic evaluation of assumptions used by cumulus parameterization. Mon. Wea. Rev1993;.121: 764-787. DOI:;2.
    30. Fritsch J.M,Chappell C.F. Numerical prediction of convectively driven mesoscale pressure systems. part 1: Convective parameterization. J. Atmos. Sci.1980;37: 1722-1733.;2.
    31. Dickinson R. E, A Henderson-Sellers and P. J Kennedy. Biosphere-Atmosphere Transfer Scheme (BATS) version 1e as coupled to the NCAR Community climate model,NCAR technical note NCAR/TN-387+STR.1993; 72pp. doi:105065/D67W6959.
    32. Ahmadi M,Lashkari H, Keikhosrav Gh,Azadi M. Comparison of LARS_WG and RegCM4 models in simulation and post-processing of annual temperature and rain fall data in Great Khorasan,journal of Sepehr.2016;25:157-170. [Persian].
    33. Naserzadeh M,Ghasemifar E, Motamedi M, Analysis Drought for Observed and Future period using downscaling models (LARSWG and SDSM) in southern coastal of Caspian Sea, Geography and planning of urban and regional.2016;20:203-222. [Persian].
    34. Ghasemifar E. Investigation of regionalization of climate change over coast of caspian sea.MA thesis, supervisior:Bohloul Alijani,2012.Kharazmi University. [Persian].
    35. Tiwari PR,Chandrakar S,Mohanty UC,Dey S,Sinha P,Raju PVS,Shekhar MS, The role of land surface schemes in the regional climate model (RegCM) for seasonal scale simulations over Western Himalaya, Atmósfera.2016: 28(2), 129-142.
    36. Daniel A, Changes in extreme precipitation events over the central United States in AOGCM-driven regional climate model simulations, Graduate Theses and Dissertations in Agricultural Meteorology,2015.