A Framework to Achieve a Shared Vision in the Collaborative-Strategic Management of Water (Case study: Kashafrood basin)

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Ph.D. Student of Water Engineering, Irrigation and Drainage, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

2 Professor of Water Engineering, Irrigation and Drainage, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

3 Professor of Management Department, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

4 Assistant Professor of the Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahid Beheshti University

Abstract

The shared vision is the main element of planning in the field of water management and the core of all the tasks of the actors. The vision of water management in Iran is to achieve sustainable development. But the lack of a clear framework for achieving sustainable development in the country's water management is significant. This can be achieved through collaborative-strategic planning. The present study, as a targeted action integrating internal and foreign trade, has provided a systematic framework for achieving a shared vision in collaborative-strategic management of water and has been implemented in Kashafrood basin. This framework is presented in three steps. In the first step, the actors of the basin are identified by Snowball method. then by using the Mind Map method their concerns were extracted and thereafter the basin vision was developed. In the second step, strategies for achieving the vision were identified by using the Freeman method and then the policy of achieving these strategies was developed. In the third step, a questionnaire was used to assess the capability of implementation and the impact of macro policies, and ultimately, executive policies were developed to achieve relevant macro policies. The results of this study led to the development of a common perspective on the 1420 horizon in the Kashafrood basin, in which this basin will have a sustainable balance in water resources and consumption. Under this vision, 19 strategies, 63 macro policies and 232 executive policies have been developed, 41% of which have a social nature. The evaluation of the implementation and effectiveness of policies reflects the high consensus among actors on the implementation and effectiveness of policies to achieve the shared vision of the Kashafrood basin.

Keywords

Main Subjects


[1]. Salvador I, Pérez U, José M, Ponce O, Arturo JG. A multi-objective optimization approach for sustainable water management for places with over-exploited water resources. Computers & Chemical Engineering. 2019; 121(2):158-173.
[2]. Ferrero G, Setty K, Rickert B, George S, Bartram J. Capacity building and training approaches for water safety plans: A comprehensive literature review. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, in press, corrected proof. 2019.
[3]. Parreño A, Femenia R, Caballero J, Labarta J, Grossmann I. Sustainable Optimal Strategic Planning for Shale Water Management. Computer Aided Chemical Engineering. 2018; 43(1):657-662.
[4]. Jaeckel A. Strategic environmental planning for deep seabed mining in the area. Marine Policy, In press, corrected proof. 2019.
[5]. Wani SP, Garg KK. Watershed Management Concept and Principles. In: Best-bet Options for Integrated Watershed Management Proceedings of the Comprehensive Assessment of Watershed Programs in India. ICRISAT Patancheru, Andhra Pradesh, India. 2009;2(11):25-27
[6]. Omariani Khorasani H, Davary K, Bagheri A, Qaisani A. Implementation of "Strategic Water Resources Management"; a proposed framework using the Roadmap tool. Water and Sustainable Development. 2014;2(1):11-26. [Persian]
[7]. Pourfadakari S. Status of Water Management and Planning in Iran and the World. First meeting of demand management and water consumption productivity. Hamedan. 2015. [Persian]
[8]. Jafarian V, Yazdani MR, Rahimi M, Ghorbani M. Analysis of the Functioning and Position of Organizational Clients in Garmsar Plain Water Management Executive Network. ECOhydrology. 2017;4(4):1011-1024. [Persian]
[9]. Rastgar Sh, Ahmadi Gattab H. Identification and Analysis of Factors Affecting the Participation of Operators in the Biological Actions of Sajjad┼źd Basin, Mazandaran Province. ECOhydrology. 2018;5(2):687-698. [Persian]
[10].            Juwanaa I, Muttilb N, Perera BJC. Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis of West Java Water Sustainability Index – A case study on Citarum catchment in Indonesia. Ecological Indicators. 2016;61(1):170–178.
[11].            Sorrafzadeh MA. Sustainable Management of Resources and Water Consumption in Industries. Journal of Water and Wastewater Science and Engineering. 2017;2(4):23-34. [Persian]
 
[12].            Asad Allahi Z, Danekar A. Sustainable management of basin ecosystem in wetlands. National Conference on Human, Environment and Sustainable Development. Islamic Azad University, Hamedan Branch. 2009. [Persian]
[13].            Chaves H, Alipaz S. An integrated indicator based on basin hydrology, environment, life, and policy: the Watershed Sustainability Index. Water Resource Management. 2007;21(5):883–895.
[14].            Salarian M. Development of water resources and new managerial changes in irrigation. Water and Sustainable Development. 2014;1(2) 12-24. [Persian]
[15].            Zarghami M. Moving to successful water governance with the co-operation of knowledge and collective wisdom: the idea of establishing a local water assembly. The Journal of Water and Sustainability. 2017;4(2): 1-15. [Persian]
[16].            Mugagga F, Nabaasa BB. The centrality of water resources to the realization of Sustainable Development Goals (SDG). A review of potentials and constraints on the African continent. 2016.
[17].            United Nations General. Sustainable Development Goal 6. Clean water and sanitation. United Nations Publications. 2018.
[18].            Mohammadi M. A look at the challenge of sustainability of water resources in Iran. Human and environmental magazine. Online publication. 2018;4(7):29-39. [Persian]
[19].            Alipour A, Derakhshan H, Davary K. Strategies for Achieving Sustainable Groundwater Management. Strategic Policy Studies. 2018;8(29):261-275. [Persian]
[20].            Buchanai MH, AfrasiabadiRad MS, Yousefi H, Ebadati N. The Effect of Water Resources on Sustainable Development of Rural Areas in the Zigzag Village of the Aligudarz County. ECOhydrology. 2017;4(1):13-27. [Persian]
[21].            Arfanuzzaman MD, Atiq Rahman A. Sustainable water demand management in the face of rapid urbanization and ground water depletion for social–ecological resilience building. Global Ecology and Conservation. 2017;10(1):9-22.
[22].            Upadhyaya A. Integrated Water Resources Management and Climate Change Adaptation Strategies. Division of Land and Water Management. ICAR Research Complex for Eastern Region. Patna, India. 2018.
[23].            Akanni A. Decision Management Tools for Trans-Boundary Water Management in Lake Chad Basin. Journal of Water Resources and Ocean Science. 2018;7(4):23-35.
[24].            Pablo A, Garcia Ch, Daniel G, Neary DF, Scott RG, Benyon TR. Forest management and the impact on water resources: a review of 13 countries. Publisher: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. 2017.
[25].            Zaman A, Swaminathan MS. Participatory approach on water management for food security vis-à-vis sustainable agriculture. MOJ Food Process Technol. 2018;6(2):166–168.
[26].            Mushi Zadeh R, Salehian S. Water Resources and its Role in Sustainable Regional Development (Case Study of the Badrue Region of Isfahan). Geospatial Space Magazine. 2018;5(17):55-66. [Persian]
[27].            Governor of Khorasan Razavi, Deputy Director of Planning. Planning review of provincial land use studies. 2013 [Persian]
[28].            Palmer RN, Cardwell HE, Lorie MA, Werick W. Disciplined Planning, Structured Participation, and Collaborative Modeling – Applying Shared Vision Planning to Water Resources Journal of the American Water Resources Association. 2013.
[29].            Walker WE, Mayer IS, Hagen ER. Shared Vision Planning as Policy Analysis: Opportunities for Shared Learning and Methodological Innovation. World Environmental and Water Resources Congress. 2010.
[30].            Lan T, Lan Y, Chen K, Lin W. A Study of Developing a System Dynamics Model for the Learning Effectiveness Evaluation. Mathematical Problems in Engineering. 2013;1(1):1-6.
[31].            Eden C. Ackermann, F. Making Strategy: The Journey of Strategic Management, London: Sage Pub-lications. 2004.
[32].            Elsawah S, Guillaume J, Guillaume J, Filatova T, Jakeman A. A methodology for eliciting, representing, and analyzing stakeholder knowledge for decision making on complex socio-ecological systems: From cognitive maps to agent-based models. Journal of Environmental Management. 2015;15(2):500-516.
[33].            Vaseteh V. The Pattern of Participatory and Integrated Management of Water Resources and Consumption Based on the Balanced Experience of the Esfarayn Study Range. Sustainable Water and Development. 2017;2(1):14-15. [Persian]
[34].            Shafiei M, Karimi P. Water accounting: the need to define a new mission of the National Bureau of Basic Studies of the country's regional water companies with a view to changing the approach from "raw data production" to "alchemy". Sustainable Water and Development. 2017;4(2):16-18. [Persian]
[35].            Saidan M. Pricing and Tariff System for Water Services Agricultural Water Tariffs. The first joint meeting with water and environmental specialists. 2013;4(9):32-41. [Persian]
[36].            Bayat P, Sabouhi Saboni M, Kikha AA, Ahmadpourbarzajani M, Karami E. Effectiveness and modification of existing laws and their impact on water sector performance: the application of path analysis. Agricultural Economics and Development. 2016;24(1):167-190. [Persian]
[37].            Rasuli MB. Social Capacity, Information, and Culture in the Water Field; High Concerns and Low Operations. 2017;2(1)19-21. [Persian]
[38].            Sarvestani M, Khadri F, Delphi A, Jahanfar M, Asadi A. Achievements of Water Companies Formation in Water Resources Management. First National Irrigation and Drainage Congress of Iran. Mashhad. 2015. [Persian]
[39].            Davari dehkardi F, Baqa'i H, Parvin A, Sarvestani M. Explaining the necessity of creating water bodies and transferring management to them in water resources projects. National Conference on Sustainable Development and Sustainable Development, Focusing on Risk Reduction in Natural Disasters. Mashhad. Khavaran Higher Education Institution. 2013. [Persian]
[40].            Alwani M, Khosravi M. The Role of Information Management Systems in Decision Making. Management Studies (Improvement and Transformation). 2016;12(47):81-98. [Persian]
 
[41].            Ramezani Gh, Salimi J. Identification of knowledge management components and their implementation status; (Case study: Kurdistan University). 2015;2(5):1-24. [Persian]
[42].            Jahromi A, Zamani GH, Hayati H, Sadeghi MH. The Law of the Root of Water: An Investigative Study on the Law "Determining the Water Wells without Utilization License". Journal of Irrigation and Water Engineering. 2014;5(18):126-144. [Persian]
[43].            Salarian M, Samiy MJ, Rasooli MB. Review of the rules of the groundwater of Iran (Bugs and Solutions). National Conference on Water Rights - Opportunities and Solutions. Tehran, Hall of Summit of Islamic Countries. 2016;1(1):15 -24. [Persian]
[44].            Razavi S, Davary K. The role of virtual water in water resources management. Journal of Water and Sustainable Development. 2013;5(1):12-25. [Persian]
[45].            Kiani, GH. Role of market in optimal allocation of water resources and factors affecting water market efficiency. Journal of Water and Sustainable Development. 2016;3(1):93-102.
[46].            Mahmoudi A, Pious A. Economic Modeling of Agricultural Water in Tehran with Emphasis on the Role of Water Market. Economic Modeling. 2016;3(35):121-140.
[47].            Mokhtari A, Noori H. The water market, with a focus on reviewing the law of fair distribution of water, the second national conference on conservation of natural resources and environment, Ardebil, Mohaghegh Ardebil University. 2015.
Volume 6, Issue 4
January 2020
Pages 865-886
  • Receive Date: 30 March 2019
  • Revise Date: 15 July 2019
  • Accept Date: 15 July 2019
  • First Publish Date: 22 December 2019